Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label immigration court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label immigration court. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 4, 2017

How to file a 212H waiver in immigration court

Alright, this is a short and dirty posting today. I was doing research online, and noticed that there is a dearth of "how to" guides on 212(h) waivers. The 212(h) waiver is valid for LPR's who originally adjusted their status while in the US. Although 212(h) was designed for first time applicants, it is most often used (in the immigration court context) by LPR's who are returning from overseas, are stopped at the border by CBP (Custom and Border Protection).

Section 212(h) of the Immigration and Nationality Act provides that the Attorney General may, in his/her discretion, waive the application of subparagraph 212(a)(2)(A)(I) (crimes involving moral turpitude), 212(a)(2)(B) (multiple criminal convictions), 212(a)(2)(D) (prostitution and commercial vice), 212(a)(2)(E) (certain aliens who have asserted immunity from prosecution), and 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(II) (an offense of simple possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana). See, EOIR Judge's Benchbook regarding 212(h) relief. Additionally, In Matter of J-H-J-, 26 I.&N. Dec. 563 (BIA 2015), the waiver was extended to individuals who are convicted of aggravated felonies.

There are two types of 212(h) defenses:

1. If your client has been in the US for 15 years or more, BEFORE the filing of the 212(h). Note, this is NOT before the commission of the crime (or conviction thereof), rather before the 212(h) is filed.

2. If your client has NOT been in the US for 15 years, then he/she can file for a 212(h) on a showing of extreme hardship to a US Citizen of LPR family member. This is the same standard as the I-601.

To request type (2) relief above in immigration court, the attorney must file an I-601 with USCIS including paying the appropriate filing fees. Proof of payment of the fees, along with proof of mailing, is sufficient to initiate a 212(h) defense in the Court. You need to submit the filed I-601 and proof of payment (copy of the check and proof of mailing is usually sufficient), to request this relief.

No filing with USCIS is required when requesting 212(h) relief of type (1) above, as no hardship must be shown. This is merely an alternative to LPR cancellation.

Given that the LPR is likely detained (arriving aliens cannot get bond), make sure you have a 212(h)/601 application ready at the first hearing. This will allow you to request the earliest possible trial (merit's hearing) date.



Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 150
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864
admin@hanoverlawpc.com

Thursday, August 11, 2016

Evidence and opening statements in Immigration Court

A colleague asked me about the rules of court, regarding evidence in immigration proceedings. I thought I would share the answer here:

I have a CAT only IH coming up. I want to introduce a news article that I feel is relevant. Can I refer to the article in my opening statement?

Sure you can! You need to submit the article, and any other evidence you want to use, 15 days in advance -- unless for good cause you can’t do that. At the beginning of the hearing, the judge will review the evidence, and admit/deny as appropriate (almost always admit in CAT – it becomes a question of weight, not admissibility). In a state or federal court, the opening statement is limited to facts. However, if you had a pre-trial exchange of exhibits, you could certainly cite to a “fact” in your exhibits, too. You would do that (and in immigration court, too!) by saying something like this: “Not only will my client testify that giant green elephants are the cause of his fear, the evidence will show that as of 31 February 2016 (date of the article), the citizens of Ubuland are afraid of the government, and believe that they will all be killed by the green elephants with the governments agreement or even assistance.”. In state or federal court, you need to lay a foundation and provide authentication for evidence, before it can be admitted. Usually, you can file a motion in limine regarding certain documents, such as newspaper articles, in order to have the Court recognize the authenticity and foundation of new print prior to trial. That is not required in immigration court.

In an immigration context, you can even bring in hearsay in the opening, closing, and throughout the trial.

Do you have an immigration question? Give us a call! 1-800-579-9864 or admin@hanoverlawpc.com.

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 150
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864
admin@hanoverlawpc.com

Sunday, December 20, 2015

Overstaying Your VISA: duration-of-stay (D/S) stamp on the I-94 offers a way out

Just a quick footnote. I was speaking with a client today about her son who was out-of-status and had been since 2013. She was an LPR, but he was bum out of luck. Or was he? He arrived in the US with his parents in 1997 under the J2 category. Duration was "D/S". Everyone else adjusted, however, he did not. What relief does he have?

Turns out, he has quite a bit. Because he never received any notice from USCIS, or a judge, that the duration was expired, he is out-of-status, but has not accrued unlawful presence. What, you say!? The actual USCIS memo dealing with this is entitled: "Period of stay authorized by the Attorney General after 120-day tolling period for purposes of section 212(a)(9)(B) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (the Act)" written by then Executive Associate Commissioner for the Office of Field Operations, Michael A. Pearson (2000). In pertinent part, it reads:

(2) Counting of Unlawful Presence for Nonimmigrants. An alien who remains in the United States beyond the period of stay authorized by the Attorney General is unlawfully present and becomes subject to the 3- or 10-year bars to admission under section 212(a)(9)(B)(i)(I) and (II) of the Act. Under current Service policy, unlawful presence is counted in the following manner for nonimmigrants. (A) Nonimmigrants Admitted until a Specific Date. Nonimmigrants admitted until a specific date begin accruing unlawful presence on the date the period of admission authorized by the Service expires, as noted on the arrival document issued at the port-of-entry. (B) Nonimmigrants Admitted Duration of Status (D/S). Nonimmignants admitted to the United States for D/S begin accruing unlawful presence on the date the Service finds a status violation while adjudicating a request for another immigration benefit, or on the date an immigration judge finds a status violation in the course of proceedings. If, however, the immigration judge concurrently issues voluntary departure and the alien complies with the order by making a timely departure, no unlawful presence accrues. See sections (d)(2) and (d)(5) of this chapter regarding voluntary departure as a period of stay authorized by the Attorney General.


Use this information to jam unlawful presence arguments when applying for various USCIS status changes for D/S candidates.

Note that D/S is valid even if served an NTA, as only an immigration judge can stop the duration of the stay - i.e. a mere notice of filing does not trigger a break in lawful presence. Remember, though, that lawful presence is not the same as legal status.

Do you have a question about immigration law? Contact us at 703-402-2723 or 1-800-579-9864. We are here to help!

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 150
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
Lili O'connell, Esq.
Charles Hatley, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com

Friday, July 31, 2015

Post Immigration Court -- what happens if I lose?

A colleague of mine asked for information on what happens after an adverse decision by the Immigration Court. The Judge ruled against her client, and she sought guidance on how to proceed.
I just received word that my client's CAT and Withholding claims were denied. I am worried that I may not be able to reach him before he is transferred, and the family is in a panic.

I would like to know:
1. What happens next
2. If he exercises right to appeal, could he be eligible for interim bond/release from custody (Alien AF - conspiracy/100 kilos of marijuana is what landed him in Removal proceedings in the first place) during the wait time?
3. How do we determine where he will be taken, and how can we track his movement so that the family can try to get him some clothing, his I.D's and some money?


Any insight from those of you who have gone through this, and had to deal with the anxiety the family members are suffering, would be extremely helpful!

In answer, this is a rather complex compound question. Your client will be placed on the “depart roster.” For security reasons, DHS will not release the time or place they will fly your client out from – it largely depends on what country he is going to. If you ask nicely (and it is that random!), you are technically permitted to bring him a single suitcase before he departs. You are right to coordinate this through his D.O. (deportation officer). However, that’s about as much information and access as you will get.

If appeal rights were not waived, he’ll wait 30 days before anything happens. If he waived appeal, or 30 days elapse, then he’ll be on the next available flight. Generally, flights leave for Mexico regularly, but say, to Nepal, quite rarely indeed.

There is no bond for a detainee who is awaiting deportation. If ever there was a flight risk, that would be your fella! However, if the BIA appeal is successful, and a remand is had, you should be able to avail yourself of the six month rule (primarily in the 9th circuit, but arguable everywhere). Ping me if you need more information on this.

You can file an appeal and ask for a stay of removal pending appeal. You need to ALWAYS ask. Although, technically this should be automatic…trust nothing. I’ve actually had folks deported during their appeal and then subsequently win the appeal…and they are in yonder land. ALWAYS ask.

Do you have a question about deportation relief AFTER an immigration court hearing? Call us immediately as time is of the essence. Oh, and never waive appeal rights. 703-402-2723 or 1-800-579-9864.

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com Lili O'connell, Esq.
Abby Archer, Esq.
888 16th St., NW Ste 800
Washington, DC 20006
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 150
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com Charles Hatley, Esq.

Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Difference between JOINT filing and CONSENT filing

As a practitioner in both Federal and State jurisdictions, I am often consulted on matters that cross between both types of Courts. A recent question posted to the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) is a good example. In this case, a practitioner new to immigration law (Federal) was asking the difference between a joint filing with the opposing counsel, and a consent filing with the DHS attorney. Her question, in part, read:

I used to file "consent" motions in state criminal court when I had consulted with the prosecutor and they agreed on whatever I was asking for. I didn't have them [prosecutors] actually sign the motion...

I've been looking at a sample "joint" motion to admin close an immigration case, and there's a space for the DHS attorney to sign. Is that just a best option, or is it actually necessary for me to get OCC's (Office of Chief Counsel -- immigration equivalent of the "district attorney" for a particular court) signature on a joint motion?

Does it make a difference if I title my motion "consent" vs. "joint"?

A discussion on JOINT MOTIONS vs. CONSENT MOTIONS:


A consent motion is one that the opposing parties agrees to allow you to file – consent = no opposition. The other party consents to your filing, but takes no position on the matter.

A joint motion is one where you and another party (together) are requesting the Court take some action. A joint motion is much stronger than a consent motion. In a joint motion, all parties are arguing that the Court should grant the requested relief, and the facts alleged are true. The opposition has moved from merely agreeing to allow you to file, to actually arguing for the relief to be granted. To make an argument to the Court, counsel must sign the motion. Hence for a joint filing, all parties filing in joint must sign.

When the petitioner AND the government both file in joint (a joint motion -- in the example above, OCC and the petitioner), the government is actually obligated to argue on behalf of the motion, just as you are obligated to argue on behalf of the motion. The Court is obligated to view the requested relief as beneficial to the government (or other joint filing party) when factoring whether to grant the same, or not.

Oddly, I just had a joint motion for bond redetermination denied by the Superior Court in DC (client had a 3rd DUI and was being held on a show cause for probation violation). That is exceptionally rare, and despite my impassioned plea, and rather luke-warm, tepid support by the government, the judge did her own thing. Just goes to show no matter how strong a joint motion is, the final arbitor is always the judge!(laughing). Those of you who have had favorable plea agreements nixed by the Court are too aware of the odd quirks that a judge can take despite the agreement of all parties on how the case should move forward.

Do you have a procedural question or concern in Federal or State Court? Call us! We can help -- 703-402-2723 or 1-800-579-9864.

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com Lili O'connell, Esq.
Abby Archer, Esq.
888 16th St., NW Ste 800
Washington, DC 20006
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 580
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com Charles Hatley, Esq.

Monday, February 2, 2015

Immigration Asylum -- the 1 year clock (and other questions)

Recent questions posted on AILA about the one year clock and exceptional circumstances.


I recently answered two questions on thee AILA member board, and thought I would share both the questions and the answers here. Although these were aimed at practitioners, the answers may also be helpful to folks desiring more information on the law and how to find answers.

1) Can anyone recommend a resource for learning about standards or cases involving changed circumstances or extraordinary circumstances for late filing of asylum applications?

Answer:
Your best friend is Google and the AILA document repository. If you don’t belong to the AILA-NET/LINK whatever that is (alludes me at the moment), ask another member to run a search for you and see if there is a hit. Regardless, anything worth knowing lives on Google, and as you get more experience, you’ll post information on Google, too. Regardless, in answer to your 1st question, is it depends. Haha. Right, it depends on the circuit in which you find yourself. Your question is one of last resort – meaning that the controlling doctrine will be issued by the appeals court in the area you practice. In mine, for example, it’s the 4th circuit. Go to Lexis and look up 4th circuit cases dealing with asylum and changed country conditions. Ditto for Google. Do not be fooled by BIA – BIA is not controlling in cases of last resort. They are bound by the appeals court, too. If and only if you can find no controlling holding on an appeals case, then you go to search BIA decisions. Fortunately, BIA decisions are also on Lexis (and West, too), and many are on Google. Moral of the story --- search for controlling cases in your jurisdiction (federal appeals level).

2) If a person is in lawful immigration status when they apply for asylum then does the one year filing deadline still apply?
Answer:
Yup. One year deadline is not predicated on status. It is predicated on the clock. The asylum clock is a nasty beast, and there is extensive literature on when the clock starts and stops. You may have heard of the term “lodging an asylum application.” This refers to sneaking a package into the clerk when a defensive asylum is at risk of crossing the 1 year mark. Worse still, if the matter is not heard before the judge before the 1 year mark, it is considered late when the trial occurs (i.e. outside the filing window), and the judge will have to permit it to move forward and waive the 1 year window. Be prepared to file a motion too advance your hearing, on grounds of the 1 year window, before that happens. If you do, and the judge does not so advance, you have an excellent argument for waiving the 1 year window requirement when you are finally heard. I realize that was not the genesis of your question – but if you’ve not faced that before (1 year window while in court), file it away for a rainy day. Can save a lot of embarrassment. Back to your original question – the clock starts the moment you arrive, and only stops on certain specific events (usually delineated in the code, or placed on the record by the judge). These reasons are far between (for example, an appeal of a specific action in the asylum matter will often “stop the clock”), so you can pretty much assume, if you’ve passed the 1 year mark from the date of arrival, you’re out of the window.

For additional information on the one year clock (there was some debate on this within the AILA group), see: http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Humanitarian/Refugees%20%26%20Asylum/Asylum/AOBTC%20Lesson%20Plans/One-Year-Filing-Deadline-31aug10.pdf. This is a training manual for DHS/ICE and the immigration court staff on how to handle asylum applications. Specifically, the discussion on page 4 is instructive:

From the Asylum Training Manual:
Any asylum applicant who applied for asylum on or after April 1,1998 (or April 16, 1998, for those applying affirmatively), must establish that he or she filed for asylum within one year from the date of last arrival or establish that he or she is eligible for an exception to the one-year filing requirement. If an applicant fails to establish either timely filing of the application or that an exception applies, the application must be referred to the Immigration Court. Only an asylum officer, immigration judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) is authorized to make this determination. The determination may be made only after an interview with an asylum officer or hearing before an Immigration Judge.

Do you need help with an asylum question (either affirmative or defense) or attempting to prove exceptional circumstances for a late asylum filing? Contact us! We can help and have had great success. 703-402-2723.

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com Lili O'connell, Esq.
Abby Archer, Esq.
888 16th St., NW Ste 800
Washington, DC 20006
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 580
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com Charles Hatley, Esq.

Saturday, September 13, 2014

Understanding the term "arriving alien"

Be careful not to get your immigration client "no bond" on result of bogus allegations!


Many DHS attorneys (opposing counsel in immigration cases) do a great job, but you still need to be vigilant against your fella not getting bond or access to certain relief because the government incorrectly classifies him as an arriving alien.

The term "arriving alien" is defined in section 8 CFR 1.1(q). It is a clear definition, and you must not let DHS or ICE mis-categorize the alien:
8 CFR 1.1(q):
(q) The term arriving alien means an applicant for admission coming or at- tempting to come into the United States at a port-of-entry, or an alien seeking transit through the United States at a port-of-entry, or an alien interdicted in international or United States waters and brought into the United States by any means, whether or not to a designated port-of-entry, and regardless of the means of trans- port. An arriving alien remains such even if paroled pursuant to section 212(d)(5) of the Act, except that an alien who was paroled before April 1, 1997, or an alien who was granted ad- vance parole which the alien applied for and obtained in the United States prior to the alien’s departure from and return to the United States, shall not be considered an arriving alien for pur- poses of section 235(b)(1)(A)(i) of the Act.

A recent example on a popular listserve we work with should illustrate:

My client entered the USA with a J-1 visa. The TA said that my client is an arriving alien. NTA allegation #3 states that client was admitted as a nonimmigrant exchange visitor for duration of Status. I have been doing research but I can't find it. Would anyone tell me where to find whether or not my client is an "arriving alien".

In this example, the client received a stamp -- "D/S" and entered the country. D/S stands for "duration of status" and indicates that the individual was reviewed by a Customs and Border Patrol officer, and admitted. Per 1 CFR 1.1(q), his is no longer an applicant for admission, and therefore he is not an arriving alien.

Where your client sneaks into the US (entry without inspection or EWI), the rule is that once he has "arrived" and is not detained within 100 miles of the border, he is considered to be within the US and no longer an arriving alien for Court purposes. The 100 miles, by the way, is a rule-of-thumb, not a firm statute.

Do you have a case involving an arriving alien? We'd love to help! Give us a call at 1-800-579-9864. Do not let your case get white washed!

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com
888 16th St., NW Ste 800
Washington, DC 20006
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 580
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com Charles Hatley, Esq.
Leigh Snyder, Esq.

Monday, August 4, 2014

Get Out of ICE Detention -- When you have credible fear but remain detained.

Among one of the more perplexing aspects of immigration law is the plight of the arriving alien. Bluntly, an arriving alien without proper paperwork is going to experience a considerable amount of trouble. The procedures for an "undoc" arriving alien (aka smuggled, border jumping, etc.) are contained in 8 CFR 235.3. If the alien claims asylum, then a credible fear interview must be held. Regardless of whether the investigating officer determines fear, or if the an immigration judge later finds credible fear despite the investigating officers determination, the individual who entered the US remains in custody as an arriving alien.

There are three key steps to getting bonded out in a credible fear/arriving alien situation:
  • First, there must be a finding of credible fear by an asylum officer. The credible fear checklist is found at 8 CFR 208.30. For a more in-depth step-by-step application of 208.30, see the USCIS field training manual here.
  • Secondly, if the asylum officer declines to find credible fear, the arriving alien must ask to appear before a judge. The judge will then review the notes of the interviewing officer, discuss the case with DHS counsel and with the counsel for the arriving alien. Note -- you absolutely need an attorney here if you are planning to actual fight this. Although technically, an attorney for the alien exists only to advise the alien during a credibility determination (cannot make representations to the Court), as a practical matter, the judge usually does not question the alien further, but instead looks to the alien's attorney to explain the nexus and why, at law if all facts are properly admitted, this alien will be eligible for asylum. How to handle a credible fear hearings is the subject of a different blog.
  • Finally, if either the judge or the asylum officer has determined there is a credible fear, and that a nexus exists tying the credible fear to a protected class, the arriving alien will be eligible for parole.

Recognize that ICE parole/bond is not the same as an Immigration Court bond . An immigration court has no jurisdiction over arriving aliens (on account of the expedited removal order that is already entered upon an illegal entry into the US -- see 235.3 above). This means that an immigration judge is barred from granting bond. By statute, only ICE has jurisdiction over release of arriving aliens, even if they are placed in removal proceedings.

To obtain parole for a detained alien with a positive credible fear determination, the alien is no longer required to complete the deportation parole worksheet; however, as a practical matter, every alien should request parole and affirmatively ask to complete the worksheet once credible fear has been established. The form has no number, but an example can be found here. This should happen automatically. However, having an attorney complete the paperwork is of critical assistance to ensure no loose ends are left undone. Be sure your attorney informs the DO (deportation officer) or the DRO (detention and removal office) in charge of the alien's case that the presumption is release unless there is an overriding need to keep the alien detained (defined as safeguarding the community or national interest). See the ICE Memorandum on parole and release for more specific legal guidance on this. This memorandum has been key on several occasions to get ICE to "move along" on the parole request.

A few pointers to remember. The DO cannot complete a parole worksheet until credible fear has been established. Also remember that the arriving alien will not be paroled until an NTA (Notice to Appear -- subpoena for immigration court) has been issued with a return to court date. The reason is that once the alien is released on parole -- poof. No more alien. Unless ICE has the alien sign the NTA, there is no proof the alien received notice of the immigration court date, and no way to enforce a removal order if the alien does not show to court. Not going to happen -- ergo, no bond/parole until an NTA with a date certain return is issued. This can take a week or so after a hearing, or usually immediately is credible fear is granted by the asylum officer.

DO NOT forget to complete an AR-11 (change of address form) prior to having your arriving alien disappear on bond/parole.

What is the difference between bond and parole? From an absolute standpoint -- nothing. From a practical standpoint, a bond requires the payment of collateral in order to ensure the alien will return to court. Parole requires no payment (hence the term, "parole", which means "word" in the sense of "to give one's word").

Do you have an immigration question about arriving alients? Give us a call! We can help. Do not try to handle immigration court on your own -- this can be disastrous and lead to expedited removal without an appeal. We have specialized experience with gangs and special juvenile immigrant status (SJIS) cases. Let our expertise work for you.

Hanover Law, PC
Offices in Fairfax, VA and Washington, DC
www.hanoverlawpc.com
888 16th St., NW Ste 800
Washington, DC 20006
2751 Prosperity Ave, Ste 580
Fairfax, VA 22031
Sean R. Hanover, Esq.
Stephen Salwierak, Esq.
1-800-579-9864 admin@hanoverlawpc.com Charles Hatley, Esq.
Leigh Snyder, Esq.

Monday, April 14, 2014

Stopped by CBP - Deferred Inspection

Deferred Inspection with CBP


In this instance, there are a couple of considerations. You should expect to be placed in removal proceedings. It does not sound like you will be charged with an aggravated felony. First, this does not appear to be a crime of violence, and secondly, as you described it, it sounds like you received straight probation. As such, under sec. 1101(a)(48)(b), this probably wouldn't be an aggravated felony anyway (called "agg-fel" in our parlance).

Now, if this is NOT an aggravated felony, you might qualify for various types of relief when put into removal proceedings.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

So you are a witness...

For some people, there is great anxiety in appearing in court. This is especially true if the case in question revolves around you personally. Always a challenge! However, as trial attorneys, we have learned a few tricks that make appearing in court easier. Specifically, what the heck happens when you "go on the stand" -- this article will talk about immigration court, and state court specifically (criminal law, and family law), but it applies to any hearing where you are in adversarial proceedings.

The key thing to remember about testifying is -- everything you say can and will be used against you. It is the job of opposing counsel (or the state, in criminal cases) to try to learn everything he/she can about you, and then use that information against you, or against some individual in the trial.

Remember, you are speaking under oath. That means, if you lie, bad things can happen to you. Perjury is the act of lying under oath (to perjurer one's self).

What do attorneys ask of their clients? We want you to do the following when answering opposing counsel:
  • Answer only the question asked.
  • Keep your answer simple. Provide as little depth as possible to what is asked.
  • Be polite, and always respectful.
  • DO NOT be evasive or argumentative.
  • Stick to the story! Remember, prior to trial you will have already chatted with your attorney and described what happened. Don't change things!
  • If you get confused or don't know what to say, look at your attorney so he/she can object to buy you time.


Whenever possible, site (mention) supporting documents. Use outside evidence to bolster your story.

The VirginiaCLE website has a useful summary:
Witnesses must come to understand that there is no "truth" unless it is proved in court by persuasive evidence. An online definition of "finding of fact" reads, "the determination of a factual question vital (contributing) to a decision in a case by the trier of (jury or judge sitting without a jury) after a trial of a lawsuit, often referred to as findings of fact." And yet, the definition of a "fact" is variously "the quality of being actual," "an actual occurrence," or "a piece of information presented as having objective reality." A person limiting herself to presenting Sergeant Friday's "Just the facts, ma'am" will be presenting subjective observations as perceived by her, not unassailable truths.


Remember, work with your attorney to practice and test your statements. Tell the truth, but be ready to be thorough and be questioned. You can do this!

Do you need trial help? Call us now to get prepared for your hearing. It can make the difference between success and failure.

S

Sean R. Hanover, Esq
HanoverLawPC.com
Contact Us
703-402-2723

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

A Curious Trial: U Visas, Rape, M-A-M hearing, and CAT relief

I was recently faced with a very difficult trial. A client of mine was suffering from torture and rape in prison, and the trial to have him released had been 10 months in the making. Additionally, I was barred from seeking Federal relief because the agency that held him was neither the state, nor even a prison -- rather it was a Federal Agency: ICE. Getting reports from that agency on anything is like pulling teeth.

After a grueling 5 hour trial, I managed to secure CAT relief for my client. In a different discussion forum, I mentioned different avenues for presenting the prison rape problem. Investigations were still underway when we went to trial on the 10th of December, 2012.

I decided to write up a motion with attendant supporting documentation showing the abuse, the investigation, and various responses from state and federal agencies. Instead of serving it in open court, I discussed it with the DHS attorney before court. To say the DHS attorney was surprised would be an understatement! She scurried off upstairs, as DHS did not know what was going on with the client and ICE had put nothing into the file. Nice.

When the judge came in, I explained the situation to him. He then took the motion packet and a stack of law books and reviewed it all in his office.

The tactic I decided on was not presentation on the record, per se – rather a soft demonstration prior to commencing operations. Gave everyone time to review and help come up with a solution. Very collaborative. I got one hell of a payback for that at the beginning of the trial, but at least at this point, my “sandbagging” the court and DHS was received with only a modest amount of grumbling. I will tell you, though, that I came prepared. The motion was properly formatted, and even hole-punched at the top! (I forget that all the time on emergency motions). I digress.

The awesome aspect of this was the ability to discuss with the judge and DHS counsel the prison conditions and rape (including medical problems, and document theft/protection money payments being required from my client) prior to any hearing on my CAT claim.

The judge proceeded with the trial, but it was obvious that he wanted to find some relief for my client just to get the guy out of prison (he had been detained by ICE for 10 months).

DHS had it’s own unexpected whammy. After the trial started, we immediately went into a M-A-M hearing – which I was entirely unprepared for. I was not even clear if I should be arguing my client was competent to stand trial (he had a couple of “not-guilty” findings due to insanity defense) or if I should try to ditch the case on grounds he could never comprehend the criminal nature of his conduct. That was a tad awkward. As a foot note – for those of you who have not done M-A-M hearings, these are generally fairly straight forward question/answer sessions based on medical reports and other corroborating evidence that speaks to your clients mental capacity. As a rule of thumb, a client represented by an attorney, and who can answer questions about the nature of the NTA, allegations, and why he/she is present at the trial, will be found competent to move forward. If the client is not found competent, the court has leave to suspend the hearing until competency can be established, appoint a guardian, or even remove the case and terminate proceedings. In the instant case, it was strange because I did not know how to argue it – especially given the prison rape, the psych background, and the need to get my client out ASAP. I hate not being prepared. For those who take the class on 18 Dec – you will have that hammered into you quite well.

Regardless, the judge found the client competent to stand trial and we had very interesting trial for many hours on homosexuals and transgenders in Venezuela.

It was a great hearing – but the take away is the tactic for handling prison situations prior to an IC wholly unrelated to the matter.

Call us today to discuss your case. WE CAN HELP. However, the longer you wait, the riskier it becomes when you are finally brought before an immigration judge.

S

Sean R. Hanover, Esq
HanoverLawPC.com
Contact Us

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Marriage Fraud and INA 212 - or 237(a)(1)(H)

Marriage fraud is more common than most folks think. Application for US Citizenship and green-card status (LPR) is a long, painful road. Marriage offers a relatively rapid acceptance into the USC/LPR ranks, and is therefore extremely tempting from a fraud persepctive.

To defeat a claim of marriage fraud, some of our clients have actually attempted to to bribe their respective former spouse to recant his/her statement to USCIS that the marriage was fraudulent. Usually, it is the sworn statement of one or the other spouse that gives rise to a fraud claim. Of course, our law firm starts singing loudly at that point and covering our ears..one can never condone such conduct (perpetuating fraud and all). However, if the original nay-sayer DID recant, you would have a legal argument…

That having been said, if you really want to fight a marriage fraud, you really need to attack the original marriage and show that the spouse currently being charged with marriage fraud was NOT committing fraud. That is a state action against the other spouse to show intent during (or at the time of) the original marriage. If you can get a judgment showing that the court found the marriage to be just and true, and that the other party is intentionally misrepresenting the situation, you can make a viable argument that marriage fraud was not operative in the instant case. This is a fun argument to make, and is based, again, on a state level trial against the spouse alleging the fraud.

You won’t be able to toss the marriage fraud via a 212 waiver (asking for discretionary grant of "leniency" based on fraud) as it was not incident to arrival:
While § 237(a)(1)(H) is a deportation waiver that requires a prior admission, it also requires that, at the time of that admission, the applicant was inadmissible due to fraud or misrepresentation. The BIA has held that the waiver is not available if the fraud or misrepresentation occurred subsequent to the admission. See, e.g., Salas-Velasquez v. INS, 34 F.3d 705, 708 (8th Cir. 1994) (former §241(f) waiver unavailable where applicant entered U.S. on a valid visitor visa and subsequently entered into a fraudulent marriage with a U.S. citizen); Matter ofConnelly, 19 I&N Dec. 156 (BIA 1984) (addressing the former § 241(f) waiver).(see http://www.ailf.org/lac/pa/lac_pa_fraudwaiver.pdf)


However, if you re-apply for admission and are denied, it is possible that a 212 might be available…but that is the instance where admittance is denied based on the fraud, you and re-open the marriage fraud allegation with the intent to retry the underlying issue (in this case, the BIA has held that when reviewing a subsequent request regarding the marriage fraud, the review must be taken anew and must be a substantial consideration, not relying solely on the determination alone of the prior finding). Generally, marriage fraud is not eligible for a 212 waiver because it was not fraud at the time of entry.

An interesting aside from this (same article):
Similarly, in certain marriage fraud cases, the retroactive validation of the applicant’s LPR status is critical. Specifically, where a non-citizen has been found to have committed prior marriage fraud, but now is in a valid marriage to a U.S. citizen or LPR, INA § 204(c) would bar approval of a visa petition filed by the second spouse. Thus the non-citizen would be barred from ever immigrating through this second, valid marriage. However, in Virk v. INS, 295 F.3d 1055, 1059 (9th Cir. 2002), the Ninth Circuit held that, where the non-citizen was admitted as an LPR based upon the fraudulent marriage, the grant of a § 237(a)(1)((H) waiver would waive the underlying fraud and the non-citizen would retain LPR status. As such, the court found that there was no need for a new visa petition by the second spouse and INA § 204(c) was inapplicable


Note, however, that the in the excerpt above, it would appear the applicant was admitted as an LPR (presumably through consular processing, for example), and as such the fraud was relied upon for entry.

Marriage fraud is generally terminal -- unless the client desires to fight the underlying cause of the fraud. The time required for this is extensive, and the expenses are not trivial. Waivers are rare, and generally, like asylum fraud, the bar is permanent. However, a good lawyer can develop a compelling narrative and ensure every possible opportunity to stay is developed. This freuqently involves state court.

Call us today to discuss your case. WE CAN HELP. However, the longer you wait, the riskier it becomes when you are finally brought before an immigration judge.

S

Sean R. Hanover, Esq
HanoverLawPC.com
Contact Us